Collaborate with Mark ✅

Collaborate with Mark ✅

Share this post

Collaborate with Mark ✅
Collaborate with Mark ✅
🔒Leader's Dispatch: Humans > Algorithms (Hiring Re-Surges! Why?)

🔒Leader's Dispatch: Humans > Algorithms (Hiring Re-Surges! Why?)

Leader's Dispatch Volume 4

Mark S. Carroll ✅'s avatar
Mark S. Carroll ✅
Aug 11, 2025
∙ Paid
1

Share this post

Collaborate with Mark ✅
Collaborate with Mark ✅
🔒Leader's Dispatch: Humans > Algorithms (Hiring Re-Surges! Why?)
Share

Top of the Series: 🔒Leader's Dispatch: Has OpenAI Lost Its Strategic Edge? (Windsurf AI ☢️Fallout🧨)

Previous: 🔒Leader's Dispatch: Is "AI-Washing" Just Smart Branding?

Revenge of the Humans: Why Smart Leaders Are Re-Humanizing Work

Tagline: AI was supposed to replace us. Instead, we’re taking our jobs back—smarter, stronger, and sassier than ever.


Cold Open / The Setup

Headline: AI Promised Paradise. Then Came the Customer Complaints.

Klarna is the modern-day dowry: four easy payments and a wish
  • Klarna – Klarna proudly declared its AI could do the work of 700 customer service reps, but after satisfaction plunged it quietly re-hired humans—apparently even this fintech needed a reminder that empathy isn’t algorithmic

  • Duolingo – Duolingo’s “AI-first” plan to replace its content contractors backfired so fast that the CEO rushed to LinkedIn to insist humans are still “very essential” to the company’s success, proving even disruptors sometimes have to eat their words

In 2025, over 52% of leaders who replaced staff with AI now regret it

Takeaway: The robot uprising didn’t replace humans as well as it challenged our patience

Today’s lesson: ‘You are a disappointment in two languages now.’

What Went Wrong: The False Promise of “Fully AI-Driven”

Headline: AI Automation ≠ Optimization

  • Discuss common pitfalls of over-automating customer service, hiring, and team communication.

  • IBM – IBM replaced thousands of HR staff with AI to boost efficiency, only to quietly rehire people when its chatbot handled sensitive workplace issues with all the nuance of a flowchart—apparently even Big Blue needs a human touch in HR after all

  • McDonald’s – McDonald’s beta-tested an AI drive-thru but pulled the plug after the bot’s absurd order mix-ups (adding ketchup to ice cream and conjuring phantom extra McNuggets) went viral on TikTok—prompting the golden arches to recall that sometimes you really do need a human on the headset

Step 1: Fire thinkers. Step 2: Buy AI. Step 3: Wonder why everyone’s walking into walls.

Leader’s Dispatch Just the Facts!

  • Decline in satisfaction with AI-only support: After replacing 700 human agents with chatbots, fintech firm Klarna saw customer satisfaction drop by 22% – a decline that forced the company to rehire human support staff

  • Reversals of AI-based HR policies: Over 55% of companies that enacted AI-driven layoffs later regretted the decision. Many firms have had to rehire staff or roll back automated HR initiatives when promised efficiency gains failed to materialize, underscoring the cost of overreach.

  • Trust and psychological safety issues: Heavy-handed AI monitoring can erode trust. Research shows that companies using AI surveillance see almost 2× higher employee turnover than those that don’t, indicating how constant monitoring and sentiment-analysis tools can sap workers’ sense of safety and loyalty.


🗳️ Poll: Have you ever been ‘helped’ by an AI assistant that made things worse?

  • 🤖 Yes, I begged for a human

  • 🪵 No, I enjoy emotional voids

  • 🤯 What do you mean this wasn’t a real person?!

  • 🧾 It took my order, my dignity, and then my credit card

  • 🧘 I’ve accepted that confusion is part of the journey


Loading...

⏸️ A Quick Intermission from the AI Frenzy…
Before we dive back into the post-AI-boom era and humanity’s grand resurgence, here’s a quick detour — a sneak peek at an opportunity that’s very human, very now, and very fixable:

Collaborate Better is your backstage pass to the absurd yet fixable drama of modern teamwork. Think: The Office meets The Art of War — but with post-its, power plays, and a dash of improv.

It skewers the myth of the Lone Genius and shows how real progress happens when egos get offstage and collaboration takes center spotlight.

Whether you're the overwhelmed manager, the silent Zoom square, or the team member nodding while secretly Googling ‘what is a stakeholder’ — this book hands you the script for building trust, alignment, and actual results.

TL;DR: It’s Downton Abbey with Agile values. And everyone’s invited to the table — yes, even the rugged individualist in the corner with a Gantt chart and a dream.

Don’t wait until it’s on your manager’s desk. Get it on yours first.

The Rebound: Why Humans Are Coming Back

Headline: The Return of the Soft Skills

Keep reading with a 7-day free trial

Subscribe to Collaborate with Mark ✅ to keep reading this post and get 7 days of free access to the full post archives.

Already a paid subscriber? Sign in
© 2025 Mark S. Carroll
Privacy ∙ Terms ∙ Collection notice
Start writingGet the app
Substack is the home for great culture

Share